Nate silvers the signal and the noise is the soul of a new machine for the 21st century a century we thought wed be a lot better at predicting than we actually are. Numbers in one form or another may be the project of silvers life, but at times. Rachel maddow, author of drift a serious treatise about the craft of predictionwithout academic mathematicscheerily aimed at lay readers. Why so many predictions failbut some dont is nate silvers 2012 meditation on prediction, which investigates how we can distinguish a true signal out of the vast universe of noisy data. Not too surprisingly, a lot of the questions were about politics and baseball. In his book the signal and the noise, nate silver presents this example application of bayess theorem on pp. His ambitious new book, the signal and the noise, is a practical handbook and a philosophical manifesto in one, following the theme of prediction through a series of case studies ranging from hurricane tracking to professional poker to counterterrorism. This book is about predictions in many domains besides politics. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders.
Silvers interview with donald rumsfeld about pearl harbor and 911 is awesome. Why so many predictions failbut some dont by nate silver. Which is why its slightly heartbreaking to read in the introduction to silvers new book, the signal and the noise, that, having set out to write a geekconquersworld tellall in the. Why so many predictions fail but some dont, silver explains the prediction paradoxthat it is only by adopting a true appreciation for uncertainty that one can form a more accurate picture of how things will likely unfold. Why so many predictions fail but some dont is a 2012 book by nate silver detailing the art of using probability and statistics as applied to realworld circumstances. Distinguishing the signal from the noise requires both scientific knowledge and selfknowledge. Feb 03, 2015 nate silvers the signal and the noise is the soul of a new machine for the 21st century. The signal and the noise by nate silver the boston globe. It will be a supremely valuable resource for anyone who wants to make good guesses about the future, or who. Most predictions fail, he asserts, because most people have a.
Nate silver has done an incredible and, quite possibly an unpredictable thing with the signal and the noise. It should be noted that while silver covers a very wide range of subjects in his book, i eschew many of these subjects, and focus mostly on the economy and a couple of political and social issues here. Nate silver is the kurt cobain of statistics his ambitious new book, the signal and the noise, is a practical handbook and a philosophical manifesto in one, following the theme of prediction through a series of case studies ranging from hurricane tracking to professional poker to counterterrorism. Most of us would have assigned almost no probability to terrorists crashing planes into buildings in. The art and science of prediction, should ask people to bow down to him and. Even though people love to predict things they are not very good at it. You can buy the signal and the noise starting september 27. Yet, as nate silver, a blogger for the new york times, points out in his book, the signal and the noise, studies show that from the stock pickers on wall street to the political pundits on our. Nov 04, 2012 nate silver has lived a preposterously interesting life.
Watch the bestselling author of the signal and the noise. We dont know yet whether nate silvers forecast of the 2012 election. Oct 18, 2012 nate silvers new book could not be better timed or more necessary for this election. The signal and the noise, by nate silver the new york times. It will be a supremely valuable resource for anyone who wants to make good guesses about the future, or who wants to assess the guesses made by others. What follows is a full executive summary of the signal and the noise. The signal is what were looking for in the data, and the noise is all the stuff in the data that gets in the way of what were looking for. Nate silvers signal and the noise examines predictions. I would encourage you to view this as a group opinion. Silvers coverage is polymathic, ranging from poker and earthquakes to. The signal and the noise nate silvers fivethirtyeight.
Even better, the first paragraph of the introduction tells us that the book is about the things that make us smarter than any computer and how we learn, one step at a time. The signal and the noise, by nate silver the new york. In the signal and the noise, silver looks at analysts in many fields, from weather to the economy to national security, and concludes that those who. The 12 coolest things we learned from nate silvers brand new book. Why so many predictions fail but some dont, is about the explosion of data available in the internet age, and the challenge of sorting through it all and making thoughtful decisions. Oct 15, 2012 what follows is a full executive summary of the signal and the noise. He has written an extremely good book when he didnt even have to. Why so many predictions fail but some dont the signal and the noise by nate silver the signal and the noise explains why so many expert predictions today fail spectacularly, and what statistical and probability tools are more up to the task of predicting realworld phenomena. I compiled a list of the takeaway points that i found most relevant to the project. Nate silvers known for accurately predicting the outcome of the 2012 u. Nate silvers the signal and the noise is the soul of a new machine for the 21st century. Kaifu lee one of the worlds most respected experts on artificial intelligence reveals that china has suddenly caught up to the us, the leader in ai, at an astonishingly rapid pace. One problem is that these days the noise is increasing faster than the signal.
Silvers newly published book became an overnight bestseller. The data was clear and the sports books new this, but that doesnt sell well, does it. Silver is the statistics whiz behind five thirtyeight, the political forecasting blog he started in. From the stock market to the poker table, from earthquakes to the economy, he takes us on an enthralling insiders. The signal and the noise is a terrific book, with much to admire. Politics, baseball, and poker bill gates gates notes. Silver notes studies that show that in any given year, about 4 percent of. Nate silver is the founder and editor in chief of fivethirtyeight and the author of the signal and the noise. The 12 coolest things we learned from nate silver s brand new book.
The title of silvers book the signal and the noise presents an important and sometimes overlooked part of this science. Nate silver confuses cause and effect, ends up defending. Silvers insistence is that the quintillions of bytes of. Sep 27, 2012 because of their appreciation of probability, they can distinguish the signal from the noise. While the printing press paid almost immediate dividends in the production of higher quality maps,10 the bestseller list soon came to be dominated by heretical religious texts and pseudoscientific ones. I think that they might be of independent interest to the less wrong community, and so am posting them here. Nate silver s the signal and the noise is the soul of a new machine for the 21st century. Nate silver has made a career out of predicting things better than other people. Has anyone read nate silvers new book the signal and the. What are some books like nate silvers the signal and the. The international bestseller by the galileo of number crunchers independent in the signal and the noise, the new york times political forecaster nate silver, who accurately predicted the results of every state in the 2012 us election, reveals how.
Silver s coverage is polymathic, ranging from poker and earthquakes to. Nate silver reveals which predictions are valuable and which are not in his book the signal and the noise. Some highlights from nate silvers the signal and the noise. Rachel maddow, author of drift nate silver built an innovative system for predicting baseball performance, predicted the 2008 election within a hairs breadth, and became a national sensation as a bloggerall by the time he was thirty. In his recent book the signal and the noise, he correctly describes the discipline of making predictions, without explicitly invoking the math. Though silver s book is well written, the content itself was not very fascinating or inaccessible to som. Which is why its slightly heartbreaking to read in the introduction to silvers new book, the signal and the noise, that. As silver notes, the instinctual shortcut we take when we have too much. I just started it and im enjoying it but im not a statistician and am wondering if any experts have taken a look. The first thing to note about the signal and the noise is that it is modest. Sep 26, 2012 but here comes our advance copy of nate silvers the signal and the noise. With everything from the health of the global economy to our ability to fight terrorism dependent on the quality of our predictions, nate silvers insights are an essential read. In that sense, the signal and the noise could be an important book, even if it is not actually a great one.
Nate silvers the signal and the noise is the soul of a new machine for the. Political forecaster nate silver, who has made the frontiers of digital speculation his comfort zone, wants you to learn one thing above all else from the signal and the noise. In the signal and the noise, the new york times political forecaster nate silver, who accurately predicted the results of every state in the 2012 us election, reveals how we can all develop better foresight in an uncertain world. Our political discourse is already better informed and more datadriven because of nates influence. Nothing is more common than for someone like silvera media phenom with a strong platform his 538 blog to create a book to cash in on his 15 minutes. We recently solicited your questions for nate silver regarding his new book the signal and the noise. Dec 20, 2012 crossposted on naked capitalism i just finished reading nate silvers newish book, the signal and the noise. Nate silvers fivethirtyeight uses statistical analysis hard numbers to tell compelling stories about elections, politics, sports, science, economics and lifestyle. Why most predictions fail but some dont shares his insights. It subsequently reached the new york times best seller list for nonfiction, and was named by as the no.
Just because a prediction is wrong, that doesnt mean its a bad prediction. In terms of a laymanpopular explanation of a technical field, i find the following books similar to nate silver s the signal and the noise. Why some predictions failbut some dont by nate silver. The signal and the noise by nate silver the elements of statistical learning by. Nate silvers the signal and the noise the washington post. Silvers discussion of alternatives to the bayesian approach is dismissive, incomplete, and. Rachel maddow, author of drift nate silver built an innovative system for predicting baseball. Jan 12, 2014 in terms of a laymanpopular explanation of a technical field, i find the following books similar to nate silvers the signal and the noise. In the 2012 presidential election, silver correctly predicted the winner of all 50 states and the district of columbia. The art and science of prediction, should ask people to bow down to him and that he should call himself lord and god of the algorithm. Silver s newly published book became an overnight bestseller. Why so many predictions fail but some dont, silver explains the prediction paradoxthat it is only by adopting a true appreciation for uncertainty that one can form a. Why most predictions fail but some dont is a 2012 book by nate silver detailing the art of using probability and statistics as applied to realworld circumstances. The art and science of prediction 01 by silver, nate isbn.
Nate silver, now the new york times resident stathead, began earning his rep as. Nate silver built an innovative system for predicting baseball performance, predicted the 2008 election within a hairs breadth, and became a national sensation as a bloggerall by the time he was thirty. There is promise, but also major pitfalls the signal and noise from the book s title. Fivethirtyeighter nate silver answers your questions about politics, baseball, and the signal and the noise.
Im very happy that people are reading a book on modeling in such huge numbers its currently eighth on the new. Nate silver has lived a preposterously interesting life. Nov 12, 2012 ive just read his book, the signal and the noise, and while it isnt as approachable as you might expect, thats what makes it interesting. The signal and the noise is a very interesting book with mixed success. In 2012, after his triumph of predicting the outcome of the last two presidential elections and selling his fivethirtyeight blog to the new york times, nate silver accomplished what is almost impossible. Silvers book, the signal and the noise, was published in september 2012. The signal and the noise nate silver business insider. His ambitious new book, the signal and the noise, is a practical handbook and a philosophical manifesto in one.
Stats guru and political forecaster nate silver reveals why most predictions fail, and shows how we can isolate a true signal from a universe of increasingly big and noisy data. What is most refreshing about the signal and the noise is its humility. At its best, tsantn is interesting, illustrative, educational, and. Nate silvers the signal and the noise chris wilson. The book includes case studies from baseball, elections, climate change, the 2008 financial crash, poker, and weather forecasting. The signal and the noise by nate silver overdrive rakuten. The signal and the noise won the 20 phi beta kappa award in science. The signal and the noise offers a sober analysis of prediction. His ambitious new book, the signal and the noise, is a practical handbook and a philosophical manifesto in one, following the theme of prediction through a series of case studies ranging from. Bayes theorem example in nate silvers the signal and the. This time of nate silvers the signal and the noise. Silver, whose roles span blogger, consultant and analyst, will offer his views on modern prediction science and how he applies it across politics, science, sports and economics. Jan 25, 20 the signal and the noise is a terrific book, with much to admire.
1376 900 78 1204 828 1189 846 1492 208 655 889 1152 59 1334 918 993 1009 313 1156 1208 571 1506 283 1428 793 489 1501 1031 557 1309 768 655 1119 60 514 549 1026 1356 620 120